How to Select the Construction Plant?

construction plant

The selection of construction plant starts with the work, not with a preferred machine. Define the quantity, available working time, material, haul or lift cycle, ground, access and safety limits. Then compare machines by effective production and total unit cost. The lowest hire rate is not automatically the lowest-cost choice.

How to Select Construction Plant

The following workflow keeps the practical checks in the right order. It also prevents a common mistake: using a manufacturer’s rated output as though it were guaranteed site production.

  1. Define the task and required production. Record the total quantity, deadline, shifts, usable hours per shift and any sequence constraint.
  2. Reject machines that cannot work safely on the site. Check capacity at the actual radius or gradient, ground support, access envelope, overhead and underground services, visibility, exclusion zones, noise and emissions restrictions.
  3. Estimate effective production. Start with output for the proposed configuration and cycle, then apply realistic utilization and job-efficiency allowances.
  4. Match the fleet. A loader, truck, crusher or placing unit must be checked as part of one system. The bottleneck controls the output.
  5. Compare total cost. Include owning or hire charges, fuel, operator, maintenance, attachments, transport, assembly, testing and demobilization.
  6. Confirm support before mobilization. Verify the operator, manuals, inspections, spares, service response, fuel or charging arrangements and recovery plan.

Required production = work quantity / available scheduled hours

Effective production = rated or estimated output × utilization × job-efficiency factor

Unit production cost = (hourly plant cost × working hours + one-time costs) / completed quantity

Use factors between 0 and 1. Utilization represents the share of scheduled time in which the plant actually produces. The job-efficiency factor adjusts for the material, travel distance, operator, weather, congestion and similar site effects. Do not borrow factors from another project without checking the conditions behind them.

Construction Plant Selection Decision Table

Inputs to check before accepting an equipment option
Decision input What to verify Warning or rejection point
Task and capacity Material, quantity, lift or dig geometry, attachment, accuracy and required production. The capacity chart, configuration or effective output does not cover the hardest planned duty.
Ground and travel route Bearing support, slope, traction, groundwater, edges, haul-road condition and working-platform design. Ground support has not been checked for the machine’s actual load cases.
Access and working space Gate width, turning path, transport load, bridge clearance, overhead services, tail-swing, setup and later removal. The machine fits the work face but cannot be delivered, assembled, operated or removed safely.
Effective production Cycle study, fill or load factor, utilization, job efficiency, planned maintenance and weather allowance. The comparison uses brochure output without site corrections.
Fleet match Loading, hauling, processing and placing rates; queue time; standby arrangement. One unit starves or queues the others, so the quoted fleet output is not achievable.
Own or hire Expected utilization beyond this job, finance, depreciation, resale, insurance, tax treatment, hire minimums and availability. The decision compares purchase price with hire rate instead of comparable total costs.
Reliability and support Condition history, planned maintenance, parts stock, technician response, replacement plant and recovery capability. A single failure can stop critical work and no practical backup exists.
People and safety Competent operator, familiarization, visibility aids, alarms, guarding, permits, exclusion zones and emergency controls. The required operator or safety control will not be available when the plant arrives.
Noise and emissions Local limits, working hours, engine certification, ventilation, dust, noise at receptors and fuel or charging provision. The plant cannot comply with the project specification, permit or local regulation.

Cost, Hire Rate and Owning Cost

Take all factors into account if you are offered alternatives. What are the extras to the basic rate? For operated plant, these can include overtime, bonus and subsistence. Are fuel and lubricants included or excluded? Non-operated plant can sometimes be charged on a pro-rata basis for working hours above an agreed basic week.

If you are offered a larger machine than you require, take into account any additional fuel costs and check the haulage charge. Delivery or collection charges can be a significant part of the total cost, especially for short-term hire.

For owned plant, include depreciation or capital recovery, insurance, storage and other time-related costs, as well as fuel, tires or undercarriage, maintenance and repairs. For hired plant, confirm minimum hours, standby charges, damage terms, attachments, transport, fuel, operator and service responsibility. Use the company’s cost policy and local tax advice; the method here is a selection framework, not an accounting rule.

Owning Versus Hiring

Hiring is often attractive for short, specialized or uncertain work because the machine can be matched to the job and returned. Ownership becomes more attractive when future utilization is predictable and the company can operate, maintain, transport and eventually dispose of the plant effectively. Compare both options over the same period and include idle time. A machine does not stop costing money because it is parked.

Worked Production and Unit-Cost Example

A project must move 2,400 m³ of material in eight 8-hour shifts. Required production is therefore:

2,400 / (8 × 8) = 37.5 m³/scheduled hour

Two hypothetical hire options are compared below. Their rated outputs and costs are illustrative only. On a real job, obtain the output for the actual material, cycle, attachment and configuration from the supplier or manufacturer, then validate it with site records or a trial.

Illustrative comparison using declared assumptions
Item Option A Option B
Rated or estimated output 70 m³/h 55 m³/h
Utilization 0.80 0.80
Job-efficiency factor 0.75 0.75
Effective production 70 × 0.80 × 0.75 = 42.0 m³/h 55 × 0.80 × 0.75 = 33.0 m³/h
Working hours for 2,400 m³ 2,400 / 42.0 = 57.14 h 2,400 / 33.0 = 72.73 h
Hourly cost: hire + operator + fuel/lubricants $145 + $38 + $32 = $215/h $118 + $38 + $25 = $181/h
One-time mobilization and demobilization $1,600 $1,200
Estimated job cost (2,400 / 42.0) × $215 + $1,600 = $13,885.71 (2,400 / 33.0) × $181 + $1,200 = $14,363.64
Unit cost $13,885.71 / 2,400 = $5.79/m³ $14,363.64 / 2,400 = $5.98/m³
Schedule check Meets 64 scheduled hours, before contingency. Does not meet 64 scheduled hours as one unit.
Decision for this example only: Option A meets the stated production target and has the lower estimated unit cost under these assumptions. This is not a general recommendation. A change in material, haul distance, ground, operator, billing terms or fleet balance can reverse the result. Also add a reasonable schedule contingency before committing the plan.

Ground Conditions, Access and Space

Wheeled machines can be preferable where the ground and travel route allow them to work efficiently. Under soft or difficult conditions, a low-ground-pressure crawler or temporary working platform may be considered. However, average ground pressure in a brochure is not a working-platform design value. Actual reactions can change with lifting, slewing, travel, attachments, eccentric loading and slope.

Should there be any doubt about machine loadings, fully investigate them and provide adequate precautions. Particular care should be taken over the design, construction and maintenance of piling platforms and crane setup areas. Use the machine supplier’s load data and a competent geotechnical or temporary-works design where required.

Check access onto the site, loading on roads, traffic routes and escort requirements. Are there any obstructions, low bridges, overhead power cables or other structures? Will a structure built as part of the contract obstruct the machine’s removal? Is there room for tail-swing, outriggers, counterweight installation, assembly and maintenance access?

Crawler cranes and some large mobile plant require a substantial rigging area. Craneage for the erection of tower cranes or batching plants can also require considerable space. Confirm the actual transport and assembly drawings for the proposed model rather than relying on an example from another machine.

Operators, Maintenance and Service Support

If in doubt about the operation of any plant delivered to site, ask for the manual and study it. If you are still in doubt, ask the supplier for a demonstration. Ensure that the operator is competent for the machine and work under the applicable local rules, and that site personnel know the traffic plan, exclusion zones and communication signals.

The hirer is commonly expected to carry out basic daily checks, while the owner may perform major services, but this division must be confirmed in the hire agreement. Record who supplies filters, wear parts, attachments, fuel, charging equipment and breakdown support. Ask how quickly a technician, critical spare or replacement machine can reach the site.

Pre-Mobilization Checklist

  • Task, quantity, sequence and required production approved.
  • Machine configuration and attachment match the work.
  • Effective production calculation checked against the programme.
  • Fleet cycle and bottleneck checked.
  • Hire or ownership cost comparison completed on the same basis.
  • Transport route, permits, escorts and delivery slot confirmed.
  • Gate, bridge, turning, tail-swing and overhead clearances checked.
  • Ground bearing, slope and working platform accepted.
  • Underground and overhead services identified.
  • Operator competence and model familiarization confirmed.
  • Manual, capacity chart and inspection records available.
  • Guards, alarms, cameras, lights and emergency controls checked.
  • Traffic plan, spotter needs and exclusion zones arranged.
  • Fuel, charging, spill control and fire precautions arranged.
  • Noise, emissions and working-hour limits checked.
  • Daily checks, planned maintenance and defect process assigned.
  • Critical spares, service response and replacement plan confirmed.
  • Assembly, testing, demobilization and final removal route planned.

References